Filters

  • product image link
    Amish Country All-Natural Popping Corn, Baby White
    from $3.99

    product title link Amish Country All-Natural Popping Corn, Baby White

    Amish Country Popcorn

    This delicious, gourmet popcorn is made in the heart of Amish country in Berne, Indiana. Baby White is hulless, crispy, tender, small, and very whi...

    product item link View full details
    from $3.99
  • product image link
    Amish Country All-Natural Popping Corn, Rainbow Blend
    from $3.99

    product title link Amish Country All-Natural Popping Corn, Rainbow Blend

    Amish Country Popcorn

    This delicious, gourmet popcorn is made in the heart of Amish country in Berne, Indiana.Rainbow popcorn is a blend of Amish Country Popcorn favorit...

    product item link View full details
    from $3.99
  • product image link
    Baby Blues BBQ Beef Jerky 2-oz.
    $6.99

    product title link Baby Blues BBQ Beef Jerky 2-oz.

    Righteous Felon Craft Jerky

    This collaboration with Baby Blues BBQ of University City, Philadelphia, produces a sweet and spicy jerky smothered (and covered) in Baby Blues' Sw...

    product item link View full details
    $6.99
  • product image link
    Baked Enchilada Dip Mix
    $4.49

    product title link Baked Enchilada Dip Mix

    Carmie's Kitchen

    This versatile dip can be served hot or cold, and tastes just like a cheese enchilada! Allergen: dairy About Carmie's KitchenSince 1988 Carmie has ...

    product item link View full details
    $4.49
  • product image link
    Ballpark-Style Popcorn Salt 4.5-oz.
    $3.99

    product title link Ballpark-Style Popcorn Salt 4.5-oz.

    Amish Country Popcorn

    4-1/2 ounces of Ball Park style fresh popcorn salt. That's right! Ball Park style popcorn salt, season your popcorn just like you had as a kid. Rea...

    product item link View full details
    $3.99
  • product image link
    Beemans® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.
    $0.99

    product title link Beemans® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    In the 1890s, Dr. Edward Beeman of Ohio added pepsin powder (a digestion aid he gave his patients) to chicle to produce the popular Beemans Pepsin ...

    product item link View full details
    $0.99
  • product image link
    Big League Chew® Outta’ Here Original Bubble Gum 2.12 Oz.
    $2.29

    product title link Big League Chew® Outta’ Here Original Bubble Gum 2.12 Oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Big League Chew® Outta’ Here Original is the Hall of Fame Bubble Gum! Shredded bubble gum in a stay-fresh pouch that keeps the juicy flavor locked ...

    product item link View full details
    $2.29
  • product image link
    Black Jack® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.
    $0.99

    product title link Black Jack® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Black Jack Gum was the first flavored gum in the U.S., Thomas Adams added shredded licorice to chicle in 1872 & created a winner - Black Jack -...

    product item link View full details
    $0.99
  • product image link
    Bottle Caps Candy Roll
    $1.99

    product title link Bottle Caps Candy Roll

    Ellington Agway

    Pour yourself a handful of Root Beer, Cola, Cherry, Grape, and Orange— no bottle opener needed! Refreshingly sweet and so fun to eat, BottleCaps ca...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
  • product image link
    Breath Savers Wintergreen Sugar Free Mints 0.75 oz. Roll
    $1.69

    product title link Breath Savers Wintergreen Sugar Free Mints 0.75 oz. Roll

    Ellington Agway

    Sometimes you don’t have the time or tools to brush your teeth and get rid of that stale taste. When that happens, reach for your BREATH SAVERS Win...

    product item link View full details
    $1.69
  • product image link
    Bubble Yum Cotton Candy 5-Piece Pack
    $1.29

    product title link Bubble Yum Cotton Candy 5-Piece Pack

    Ellington Agway

    Your tastebuds will swirl with delight as you chew, blow and pop BUBBLE YUM Cotton Candy Flavored Bubble Gum. Each piece has the soft texture you l...

    product item link View full details
    $1.29
  • product image link
    Buttercup Farm Raw Milk
    $8.99

    product title link Buttercup Farm Raw Milk

    Buttercup Farm

    Decadent, fresh, creamy, rich, unpasteurized, raw cow's milk.  Available in half gallon glass bottles. Quarts are available from time to time as pr...

    product item link View full details
    $8.99
  • product image link
    Buttery Popcorn Topping 16-oz.
    $5.99

    product title link Buttery Popcorn Topping 16-oz.

    Amish Country Popcorn

    This is the topping to use for squeezing over your popped popcorn to get that rich buttery flavor!Ingredients: soybean oil, palm oil, artificial bu...

    product item link View full details
    $5.99
  • product image link
    Candy Cigarettes 0.42 oz Box
    $0.75

    product title link Candy Cigarettes 0.42 oz Box

    Ellington Agway

    Each pack of Candy Cigarettes contains 10 white candy sticks. Ingredients: Dextrose, Corn Starch, Corn Syrup, Tapioca, Beef Gelatin, Artificial Fla...

    product item link View full details
    $0.75
  • product image link
    Charleston Chew Classic Vanilla 1.87 oz. Bar
    $1.99

    product title link Charleston Chew Classic Vanilla 1.87 oz. Bar

    Ellington Agway

    Chewy, vanilla flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since its launch by the Fox-Cros...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
  • product image link
    Cheddar Cheese Popcorn Seasoning 5.1-oz.
    $5.99

    product title link Cheddar Cheese Popcorn Seasoning 5.1-oz.

    Amish Country Popcorn

    Cheddar Cheese seasoning for your favorite popcorn. Try it on chips, fries or whatever.CONTAINS: CHEDDAR CHEESE{(PASTURIZED CULTURED MILK, ENZYMES,...

    product item link View full details
    $5.99
  • product image link
    Chicken Enchilada Soup Mix
    $7.99

    product title link Chicken Enchilada Soup Mix

    Carmie's Kitchen

    One of Carmie's most popular soup mixes, it’s cheesy and spicy-everything an enchilada soup should be! For extra heartiness, add chicken, black bea...

    product item link View full details
    $7.99
  • product image link
    Chicken Tortilla Soup Mix
    $7.99

    product title link Chicken Tortilla Soup Mix

    Carmie's Kitchen

    One of Carmie's most popular soup mixes, we combine corn, tomatoes, cilantro and spices with a delicious broth. Top with crunchy tortilla chips and...

    product item link View full details
    $7.99
  • product image link
    Chuckles 2-oz.
    $1.99

    product title link Chuckles 2-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Irresistible Chuckles® jelly candies are coated with sugar and full of flavor. Each nostalgic candy pack contains favorite Chuckles candy in the fi...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
  • product image link
    Claeys Sanded Lemon Drops 6oz
    $2.29

    product title link Claeys Sanded Lemon Drops 6oz

    Claeys

    Claeys Old Fashioned Hard Candies have been made in the USA since 1919. This fat free candy is naturally flavored from California lemons. Now you c...

    product item link View full details
    $2.29
  • product image link
    Claeys Sanded Root Beer Drops 6oz
    $2.29

    product title link Claeys Sanded Root Beer Drops 6oz

    Claeys

    Claeys Old Fashion Hard Candy Drops have been made in the USA since 1919. This fat free candy is artificially flavored. Now you can enjoy that old ...

    product item link View full details
    $2.29
  • product image link
    Clove® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.
    $0.99

    product title link Clove® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    The original Clove flavored chewing gum. 1 Pack (5 Sticks)

    $0.99
  • product image link
    Crazy Pop Straw, Assorted Flavors
    $2.99

    product title link Crazy Pop Straw, Assorted Flavors

    Ellington Agway

    Have your pop and suck it too. Crazy Pop Straws are molded right onto a plastic straw so they can be reused again and again! They come in a variety...

    product item link View full details
    $2.99
  • product image link
    Creamed Honey 1lb Tub
    $11.49

    product title link Creamed Honey 1lb Tub

    Bee Haven Apiaries

    All natural creamed honey. Bottled by Bee Haven Apiaries (Tolland, CT). Use as a sweet spread on toast, english muffins, pancakes or fruit- whateve...

    product item link View full details
    $11.49
  • product image link
    Creme Savers Strawberries & Creme Hard Candy 1.76 oz Roll
    $1.79

    product title link Creme Savers Strawberries & Creme Hard Candy 1.76 oz Roll

    Ellington Agway

    Indulge your senses with an irresistible taste of fresh strawberries swirled in rich cream that is uniquely Creme Savers! Each roll contains (12) i...

    product item link View full details
    $1.79
  • product image link
    Dill Pickle Seasoning 5 oz.
    $5.99

    product title link Dill Pickle Seasoning 5 oz.

    Amish Country Popcorn

    It's not so crazy, Dill pickle tastes great on Popcorn!

    $5.99
  • product image link
    Dot's Homestyle Pretzels Original Seasoned Pretzel Twists 16 oz. Bag
    $7.99

    product title link Dot's Homestyle Pretzels Original Seasoned Pretzel Twists 16 oz. Bag

    Dot's Homestyle Pretzels

    Pretzel twists dusted with our original, top-secret seasoning blend. Each pretzel twist envelopes your taste buds in a delightful swirl of buttery,...

    product item link View full details
    $7.99
  • product image link
    Dubble Bubble Gum 1928 Nostalgia Box 3.5-oz.
    $2.69

    product title link Dubble Bubble Gum 1928 Nostalgia Box 3.5-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Dubble Bubble bubble gum in the original flavor is a nostalgic treat for every generation to enjoy. The nostalgic artwork gives it a yester-year ch...

    product item link View full details
    $2.69
  • product image link
    Dubble Bubble Seedlings Gum 2.04 oz
    $1.99

    product title link Dubble Bubble Seedlings Gum 2.04 oz

    Ellington Agway

    Colorful, fruit-shaped bubble gum with candy seeds. 2.04-oz. package contains 6 assorted bubble gum fruits.

    $1.99
  • product image link
    Farm Fresh Eggs 1-Dozen
    $5.99

    product title link Farm Fresh Eggs 1-Dozen

    Joe's Eggs

    Cage-free, non-fertile eggs. Source: Joe's Eggs (Hanover, CT)

    $5.99
  • product image link
    Gerrit’s Teaberry Gum
    $0.99

    product title link Gerrit’s Teaberry Gum

    Ellington Agway

    That great taste you love, is back in the original recipe. Made by Gerrit’s. Relive yester-year with Teaberry gum and experience fruit and mint in ...

    product item link View full details
    $0.99
  • product image link
    Goetze's Cow Tale 1oz Individually Wrapped Candy
    $0.79

    product title link Goetze's Cow Tale 1oz Individually Wrapped Candy

    Ellington Agway

    Cow Tales are a chewy caramel with a vanilla cream center brought to you by the same folks that make Caramel Creams. Each tale is over 6 inches lon...

    product item link View full details
    $0.79
  • product image link
    Hickory Smoke BBQ Popcorn Seasoning 5.25 oz.
    $5.99

    product title link Hickory Smoke BBQ Popcorn Seasoning 5.25 oz.

    Amish Country Popcorn

    This seasoning has just the right smoky flavor and it would be good on anything, not just popcorn!

    $5.99
  • product image link
    Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Awesome Original Bubble Gum 2-oz.
    $2.29

    product title link Hubba Bubba Bubble Tape Awesome Original Bubble Gum 2-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Hubba Bubba Awesome Original Bubble Tape Gum—What's the biggest bubble you ever blew? Was it the size of a baseball? A grapefruit? What about a bas...

    product item link View full details
    $2.29
  • product image link
    Jalapeno Cheddar Dip & Cheeseball Mix
    $4.49

    product title link Jalapeno Cheddar Dip & Cheeseball Mix

    Carmie's Kitchen

    Spicy blend of jalapenos and green chilies pair with cheddar cheese to make one of Carmie's most popular dip mixes. Allergen: dairy About Carmie's ...

    product item link View full details
    $4.49
  • product image link
    Laffy Taffy Strawberry Rope Candy
    $0.79

    product title link Laffy Taffy Strawberry Rope Candy

    Ellington Agway

    Laffy Taffy Rope recreates the classic Laffy Taffy taste in a fun, munchable rope that delivers laughs from the first bite to the last. Stretchy, b...

    product item link View full details
    $0.79
  • product image link
    Lik-m-aid Fun Dip Three Flavor Pack
    $1.99

    product title link Lik-m-aid Fun Dip Three Flavor Pack

    Ellington Agway

    So much fun, we bet you can’t dip just one! It all starts with the candy Lik-A-Stix. Lick it up and dip endlessly for the sugary sweet and mildly s...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
  • product image link
    Little Pops Early American Popcorn 24oz
    $6.99

    product title link Little Pops Early American Popcorn 24oz

    Little Pops

    Good old-fashioned taste packed into a small variety Early American seed. Taste the difference in this all natural popping corn! All-Natural Open ...

    product item link View full details
    $6.99
  • product image link
    Manana Mexican Dip & Cheeseball Mix
    $4.49

    product title link Manana Mexican Dip & Cheeseball Mix

    Carmie's Kitchen

    Carmie's original and most popular dip mix, Manana Mexican is the most pleasing blend of chilies, cumin, and other spices. About Carmie's KitchenSi...

    product item link View full details
    $4.49
  • product image link
    Maple Craft New England Style Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix 24 Oz.
    $6.99

    product title link Maple Craft New England Style Buttermilk Pancake & Waffle Mix 24 Oz.

    Maple Craft Foods

    Buttermilk is what most people would call ‘regular’ pancakes, but there is nothing regular about this mix. Maple Craft New England Style Buttermilk...

    product item link View full details
    $6.99
  • product image link
    Mini Mini Chicles Gum 0.79 oz.
    $1.19

    product title link Mini Mini Chicles Gum 0.79 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    As Delicious as they are Colorful. Remember shaking out one piece at a time or popping in five at once? This tiny childhood favorite is sure to put...

    product item link View full details
    $1.19
  • product image link
    Nik-L-Nip Mini Drinks Wax Bottles 4-Pack
    $2.29

    product title link Nik-L-Nip Mini Drinks Wax Bottles 4-Pack

    Ellington Agway

    “Bite ‘Em, Drink ‘Em, Chew ‘Em” For nearly a century, fruit-flavored, liquid-filled Nik-L-Nip Mini Drinks have been a party and holiday favorite. C...

    product item link View full details
    $2.29
  • product image link
    O.G. Hickory Beef Jerky 2-oz.
    $6.99

    product title link O.G. Hickory Beef Jerky 2-oz.

    Righteous Felon Craft Jerky

    The Righteous Felon original recipe and sweet, smoky, hickory flavor that started it all. This O.G. classic hit the streets in '96 and the jerky ga...

    product item link View full details
    $6.99
  • product image link
    Old Fashioned Rock Candy on a Stick, Assorted Flavors
    $1.79

    product title link Old Fashioned Rock Candy on a Stick, Assorted Flavors

    Ellington Agway

    ESPEEZ Rock Candy on a Stick are the most colorful and flavorful rock candy available. From fun candy favors and drink decorations, ESPEEZ Rock Can...

    product item link View full details
    $1.79
  • product image link
    Original Necco Wafers 2-oz. Roll
    $1.99

    product title link Original Necco Wafers 2-oz. Roll

    Ellington Agway

    These crispy wafers include the nostalgic flavors we all remember as a kid: Orange, Licorice, Clove, Wintergreen, Chocolate, Cinnamon, Lemon and Lime.

    $1.99
  • product image link
    Peanut Butter Cow Pie Candy 2.5oz Patty
    $3.99

    product title link Peanut Butter Cow Pie Candy 2.5oz Patty

    Baraboo Candy Company

    Peanut butter fans rejoice! Fresh roasted peanuts, covered with gourmet caramel, followed by a layer of creamy peanut butter and then smothered in ...

    product item link View full details
    $3.99
  • product image link
    Pop Rocks Blue Razz Popping Candy 0.33-oz.
    $1.49

    product title link Pop Rocks Blue Razz Popping Candy 0.33-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    POP ROCKS® is the quintessential candy brand that brings a fun snacking experience and fond memories to many generations. We have known and loved P...

    product item link View full details
    $1.49
  • product image link
    Pop Rocks Original Cherry Flavor Popping Candy 0.33-oz.
    $1.49

    product title link Pop Rocks Original Cherry Flavor Popping Candy 0.33-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    POP ROCKS® is the quintessential candy brand that brings a fun snacking experience and fond memories to many generations. We have known and loved P...

    product item link View full details
    $1.49
  • You recently viewed

    Clear recently viewed
    Liquid error (layout/theme line 457): Could not find asset snippets/widget-code.liquid
    x