Retro Favorites

  • product image link
    Old Fashioned Metal Jacks
    $8.99

    Limited Availability

    product title link Old Fashioned Metal Jacks

    House of Marbles

    Gather around for this old fashioned playground game. With each bounce grab a jack until all have been collected, then toss them back in the circle...

    product item link View full details
    $8.99
  • product image link
    Smarties Mega Double Lollies, Assorted
    $1.29

    In Stock

    product title link Smarties Mega Double Lollies, Assorted

    Ellington Agway

    Individually wrapped double-flavored Smarties lollipops. Available in assorted flavor combinations (each sold separately). When ordered online, fla...

    product item link View full details
    $1.29
  • product image link
    Candy Cigarettes 0.42 oz Box
    Out of Stock
    $0.75

    Out of Stock

    product title link Candy Cigarettes 0.42 oz Box

    Ellington Agway

    Each pack of Candy Cigarettes contains 10 white candy sticks. Ingredients: Dextrose, Corn Starch, Corn Syrup, Tapioca, Beef Gelatin, Artificial Fla...

    product item link View full details
    $0.75
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Charleston Chew Classic Vanilla 1.87 oz. Bar
    Out of Stock
    $2.39

    Out of Stock

    product title link Charleston Chew Classic Vanilla 1.87 oz. Bar

    Ellington Agway

    Chewy, vanilla flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since its launch by the Fox-Cros...

    product item link View full details
    $2.39
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Magic Growing Capsules 12-Pack, Dinosaurs
    $1.99

    In Stock

    product title link Magic Growing Capsules 12-Pack, Dinosaurs

    U.S. Toy Co.

    Drop these capsules in hot or warm water. In minutes the sponge dinosaur will appear. Package includes 12 capsules with assorted dinosaurs.Age 3+ /...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
  • product image link
    Magic Growing Capsules 12-Pack, Sea Animals
    $1.99

    In Stock

    product title link Magic Growing Capsules 12-Pack, Sea Animals

    U.S. Toy Co.

    Drop these capsules in hot or warm water. In minutes the sponge sea animal will appear. Package includes 12 capsules with assorted animals.Age 3+ /...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
  • product image link
    Tiddlywinks Classic Game
    $9.99

    In Stock

    product title link Tiddlywinks Classic Game

    House of Marbles

    The exciting traditional game of skill for the whole family!Can you Squop your opponents Wink with your Squidger? By the way, a Squidger is the big...

    product item link View full details
    $9.99
  • product image link
    Mini Mini Chicles Gum 0.79 oz.
    $1.19

    In Stock

    product title link Mini Mini Chicles Gum 0.79 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    As Delicious as they are Colorful. Remember shaking out one piece at a time or popping in five at once? This tiny childhood favorite is sure to put...

    product item link View full details
    $1.19
  • product image link
    Big League Chew® Outta’ Here Original Bubble Gum 2.12 Oz.
    Out of Stock
    $2.49

    Out of Stock

    product title link Big League Chew® Outta’ Here Original Bubble Gum 2.12 Oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Big League Chew® Outta’ Here Original is the Hall of Fame Bubble Gum! Shredded bubble gum in a stay-fresh pouch that keeps the juicy flavor locked ...

    product item link View full details
    $2.49
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Matchbox Classic Car 5-Pack, Assorted
    $7.99

    In Stock

    product title link Matchbox Classic Car 5-Pack, Assorted

    Mattel

    5-pack of Matchbox die-cast vehicles. Assorted sets, each with a theme. Assortments vary. When ordering online, assortment will be selected at rand...

    product item link View full details
    $7.99
  • product image link
    Sproing The Spring Thing Toy
    $5.99

    In Stock

    product title link Sproing The Spring Thing Toy

    Schylling

    Sproing is the amusing, entertaining spring thing! Watch this amazing spring move, bounce, and walk before your eyes. Just place it at the top of t...

    product item link View full details
    $5.99
  • product image link
    Gerrit’s Teaberry Gum
    $0.99

    Limited Availability

    product title link Gerrit’s Teaberry Gum

    Ellington Agway

    That great taste you love, is back in the original recipe. Made by Gerrit’s. Relive yester-year with Teaberry gum and experience fruit and mint in ...

    product item link View full details
    $0.99
  • product image link
    Reed's Butterscotch Hard Candy 7-ct Roll
    Out of Stock
    $1.49

    Out of Stock

    product title link Reed's Butterscotch Hard Candy 7-ct Roll

    Ellington Agway

    Traditional butterscotch hard candy. Each roll contains 7 individually wrapped candies.

    $1.49
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Reed's Cinnamon Hard Candy 7-ct Roll
    $1.49

    In Stock

    product title link Reed's Cinnamon Hard Candy 7-ct Roll

    Ellington Agway

    Traditional cinnamon hard candy. Each roll contains 7 individually wrapped candies.

    $1.49
  • product image link
    Razzles Original 1.4-oz.
    $2.69

    In Stock

    product title link Razzles Original 1.4-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    First it's candy, then it's gum! Razzles® are a sweet candy sensation that brilliantly turns into gum after a few moments of chewing. Razzles have ...

    product item link View full details
    $2.69
  • product image link
    Pop Rocks Blue Razz Popping Candy 0.33-oz.
    Out of Stock
    $1.49

    Out of Stock

    product title link Pop Rocks Blue Razz Popping Candy 0.33-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    POP ROCKS® is the quintessential candy brand that brings a fun snacking experience and fond memories to many generations. We have known and loved P...

    product item link View full details
    $1.49
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Original Necco Wafers 2-oz. Roll
    Out of Stock
    $1.99

    Out of Stock

    product title link Original Necco Wafers 2-oz. Roll

    Ellington Agway

    These crispy wafers include the nostalgic flavors we all remember as a kid: Orange, Licorice, Clove, Wintergreen, Chocolate, Cinnamon, Lemon and Lime.

    $1.99
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Chuckles 2-oz.
    Out of Stock
    $1.99

    Out of Stock

    product title link Chuckles 2-oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Irresistible Chuckles® jelly candies are coated with sugar and full of flavor. Each nostalgic candy pack contains favorite Chuckles candy in the fi...

    product item link View full details
    $1.99
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Neato! Classics Magic Rail Twirler
    $4.99

    In Stock

    product title link Neato! Classics Magic Rail Twirler

    Toysmith

    The Magic Rail Twirler is a reproduction of a classic retro toy, using magnets to allow a spinning wheel to perform gravity-defying stunts. Place t...

    product item link View full details
    $4.99
  • product image link
    Duncan Imperial® Yo-Yo, Assorted Colors
    $6.99

    Limited Availability

    product title link Duncan Imperial® Yo-Yo, Assorted Colors

    Duncan

    The Original and best selling looping yo-yo of all time! The Imperial® is the original, All-American classic. A timeless favorite, the Imperial has...

    product item link View full details
    $6.99
  • product image link
    Clove® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.
    $0.99

    In Stock

    product title link Clove® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    The original Clove flavored chewing gum. 1 Pack (5 Sticks)

    $0.99
  • product image link
    Black Jack® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.
    $0.99

    In Stock

    product title link Black Jack® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    Black Jack Gum was the first flavored gum in the U.S., Thomas Adams added shredded licorice to chicle in 1872 & created a winner - Black Jack -...

    product item link View full details
    $0.99
  • product image link
    Beemans® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.
    $0.99

    In Stock

    product title link Beemans® Chewing Gum - 0.6 oz.

    Ellington Agway

    In the 1890s, Dr. Edward Beeman of Ohio added pepsin powder (a digestion aid he gave his patients) to chicle to produce the popular Beemans Pepsin ...

    product item link View full details
    $0.99
  • product image link
    Claeys Sanded Root Beer Drops 6oz
    $2.69

    Limited Availability

    product title link Claeys Sanded Root Beer Drops 6oz

    Claeys

    Claeys Old Fashion Hard Candy Drops have been made in the USA since 1919. This fat free candy is artificially flavored. Now you can enjoy that old ...

    product item link View full details
    $2.69
  • product image link
    Claeys Sanded Lemon Drops 6oz
    Out of Stock
    $2.69

    Out of Stock

    product title link Claeys Sanded Lemon Drops 6oz

    Claeys

    Claeys Old Fashioned Hard Candies have been made in the USA since 1919. This fat free candy is naturally flavored from California lemons. Now you c...

    product item link View full details
    $2.69
    Out of Stock
  • product image link
    Original Roy Toy Miniature Log Cabin Set No. 9 The Camp
    $11.99

    In Stock

    product title link Original Roy Toy Miniature Log Cabin Set No. 9 The Camp

    Roy Toy

    A timeless classic since 1930! This original Roy Toy log building set contains 37 naturally dyed pine log pieces to build a small log cabin with on...

    product item link View full details
    $11.99
  • You recently viewed

    Clear recently viewed
    x